Difference between revisions of "Ritual dissent and assent"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
m (Scrutinize.) |
(++Snowden material) |
||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
|wish=Overall plans and solutions that are more ore resilient than consensus based techniques bring out the best in both the participants and the solution. | |wish=Overall plans and solutions that are more ore resilient than consensus based techniques bring out the best in both the participants and the solution. | ||
|so=Ritualize dissent and assent and consent to harden ideas and proposals and their decisions. | |so=Ritualize dissent and assent and consent to harden ideas and proposals and their decisions. | ||
|wish full= | |wish full=A short workshop to drive up value, and drive out fear and loathing to create overall plans and solutions that are more ore resilient than consensus based techniques bring out the best in both the participants and the solution. | ||
|background=Forces: | |background=Forces: | ||
*{{p|open space}} uses consensus, and dissent is often not allowed (taboo even). | *{{p|open space}} uses consensus, and dissent is often not allowed (taboo even). | ||
*Rituals take out the personal aspects because everybody has to go through the same process; therefore, people like rituals. | *Rituals take out the personal aspects because everybody has to go through the same process; therefore, people like rituals. | ||
*In control tests {{p|ritual dissent}} increases weak signal detection by more than 60% over consensus-based methods. As such, it facilitates {{p|weak signals, big action}}. | *In control tests {{p|ritual dissent}} increases weak signal detection by more than 60% over consensus-based methods. As such, it facilitates {{p|weak signals, big action}}. | ||
*How can you hope to bring in a culture of tolerated failure if the climate fails to allow for even the most modest of dissent. | |||
The {{p|socratic dialogue}} also helps here. | |||
|therefore full=Ritualize dissent (challenge) and assent (positive alternatives) to scrutinize and enhance proposals, stories, ideas, or whatever. Use {{p|consent}} to make a decision. | |therefore full=Ritualize dissent (challenge) and assent (positive alternatives) to scrutinize and enhance proposals, stories, ideas, or whatever. Use {{p|consent}} to make a decision. | ||
|new=Similar to a {{p|writer’s workshop}}. | |new=Similar to a {{p|writer’s workshop}}. | ||
}} | }} | ||
==Sources== | |||
*http://cognitive-edge.com/blog/entry/5532/extracting-value-from-fear-and-loathing/ | |||
{{Source | {{Source | ||
|author=David Snowden | |author=David Snowden | ||
Revision as of 12:33, 25 August 2013
…a gathering harvesting emerging solutions and breakthroughs.
✣ ✣ ✣
A short workshop to drive up value, and drive out fear and loathing to create overall plans and solutions that are more ore resilient than consensus based techniques bring out the best in both the participants and the solution.
Forces:
- open space uses consensus, and dissent is often not allowed (taboo even).
- Rituals take out the personal aspects because everybody has to go through the same process; therefore, people like rituals.
- In control tests ritual dissent increases weak signal detection by more than 60% over consensus-based methods. As such, it facilitates weak signals, big action.
- How can you hope to bring in a culture of tolerated failure if the climate fails to allow for even the most modest of dissent.
The socratic dialogue also helps here.
Therefore:
Ritualize dissent (challenge) and assent (positive alternatives) to scrutinize and enhance proposals, stories, ideas, or whatever. Use consent to make a decision.
✣ ✣ ✣
Similar to a writer’s workshop.
✣ ✣ ✣